van Kalip Demerit Thorn: Priyadarshan
April 14, 2008
I had heard on Zoom TV a while back about Priyadarshan’s latest project in Bollywood. It was to star Shahrukh Khan and Irrfan Khan, with the former Khan playing a superstar. My suspicions were immediately aroused, and then confirmed by this article. This time around Priyadarshan was copying a Malayalam movie that had only recently been made, Katha Parayumbol. It makes me extremely angry to see this talentless hack shamelessly rip Malayalam movies that were not even made by him and make such a name for himself. Hera Pheri is considered as one of the classic Bollywood comedies. How I wish people in North India would call him out for the the a**hole that he is. The Wikipedia article about him contains detailed descriptions of all his plagiarized movies. His modus operandi consists of picking a classic comedy movie, preferably one by Siddique-Lal, changing the setting to Mumbai and throwing in a few songs in exotic locations with skimpily clad females in the background. He has brought shame and embarrassment to all movie-loving Mallus and for this reason, I confer upon him the van Kalip Demerit Thorn. The bastard that he is, he might even try to contact me about the possibility of a cash prize.
My issues with Priyadarshan do not just end with his flicking of stories. It is also the quality of his Malayalam movies. Most of them are silly slapstick comedies that rely a lot on implausible mistaken identities. Sure, there have been exceptions – restrained efforts like “Mukundanetta… Sumithra Vilikkunnu“, “Kilukkam” and “Chitram“. But to me, a Priyadarshan comedy is automatically associated with half-thought out scripts and overacting. His favourite “comedy” routine can be summarized like this:
Actor 1: <some offensive statement, spoken in low breath>
Actor 2: <takes offense and gets ready for argument>
Actor 1: Alla, njan paranjathu <comment sounding similar to previous one, but meaning something totally different>
Another of his favourites is a chaotic scene at restaurant/ice cream parlour with a lot of food being thrown around. I don’t think a lot of people find Kuthiravattom Pappu with ice cream on his face that funny.
I am also offended by the fact that he is married to the actress Lissy. That someone who looks like him could be married to someone as beautiful as her should alone suffice as proof that there is no justice in this world. I am reminded of this website I recently discovered called “Hot Chicks with Douchebags” (probably NSFW). If only I had a photo of this happy couple that I could submit to this site.








April 14, 2008 at 5:55 pm
Yes, Priyadarshan sucks big time. I have been mulling over this theory that his better films like Kilukkam could have been stolen from some talented but struggling scriptwriters. Remember Udayananu Thaaram? I have no other way of explaining how a person so devoid of talent could make movies in the first place.
April 16, 2008 at 4:26 pm
[...] Mathew expresses his disappointment in Priyadarshan’s film making style, following news about his latest Bollywood project starring SRK and Irrfan Khan, and confers upon him, the “demerit thorn”. It makes me extremely angry to see this talentless hack shamelessly rip Malayalam movies that were not even made by him and make such a name for himself. Hera Pheri is considered as one of the classic Bollywood comedies. How I wish people in North India would call him out for the the a**hole that he is. [...]
April 16, 2008 at 5:29 pm
Yeah – this guy keeps ‘re-making’ Mallu movies nonstop.
Another similarly worst guy is Ilayathalapathy Vijay in tamil, who looks like a guy straight out of a B-Grade flick.
April 16, 2008 at 7:11 pm
You may be right when you say that he makes “cheap” remakes.
The same is probably true of Vijay as well.
But, I wonder if it deserves such anger and waste of your time.
Anyway, whom should you blame if Priyadarshan or Vijay can make the money they make doing what they do without breaking the law.
Looks like they have a market.
is it not unrealistic to expect everyone to want the same things from a movie?
April 16, 2008 at 9:21 pm
[...] Mathew writes The Wikipedia article about him contains detailed descriptions of all his plagiarized movies. His modus operandi consists of picking a classic comedy movie, preferably one by Siddique-Lal, changing the setting to Mumbai and throwing in a few songs in exotic locations with skimpily clad females in the background. He has brought shame and embarrassment to all movie-loving Mallus and for this reason, I confer upon him the van Kalip Demerit Thorn. [...]
April 18, 2008 at 7:31 am
It is true that he has copied movies shamelessly. But surely, he has made a market for himself, and that is no less an achievement. The means are dubious, and in the end, he turned out to be smarter than the rest. This might irk us all, but he is the one laughing his way to the bank
April 19, 2008 at 3:06 pm
but…i like poochakkoru mookuthi! assuming thenga govinda pillai, eerali and cherian nair came out of p’s own imagination, that is…
April 21, 2008 at 8:22 am
couldn’t agree more!
makes me think if ever films like Mukundetta…, Abhimanyu, Chitram were mere accidents. Even then one must appreciate the visual aesthetics he somehow manages in his movies, especially songs.
And many of his hit movies must be credited to the scriptwriters like Srinivasan and Venu Nagavally..
April 29, 2008 at 7:57 pm
agree on the lissy part man, what a chick.
then again, copying stuff is his style, i’m at home with that. the fact that Departed was a remake does not undermine marty right?
but yeah the credits should be given…
but know what…except for Laysa Laysa…there wasnt a controversy surrounding any other movie on the credit part..wonder why
again…agree on the lissy part man, what a chick.